top of page

Ultimate STR Revenue Management Guide to Competitor Rate Analysis

Writer's picture: Chase GillmoreChase Gillmore

Updated: 1 day ago

  • Why It Matters: Competitor rate analysis helps you set the right prices, stay competitive, and boost your revenue.
  • Key Pricing Factors: Location, amenities, seasonal demand, and local events all influence rates.
  • Top Tools: Use platforms like PriceLabs, Beyond Pricing, or Wheelhouse to automate pricing decisions.
  • Dynamic Pricing Tips: Adjust rates for demand, occupancy, and events. Offer discounts for early bookings and long stays.
  • Metrics to Monitor: Focus on ADR (average daily rate), Occupancy Rate, and RevPAR (revenue per available room).

How to Use Dynamic Pricing Software for Short-Term Rentals


Rate Analysis Tools

Picking the right tools for rate analysis is a key step in managing STR pricing effectively.


Leading Market Tools

The STR industry commonly uses three main pricing tools:

Tool

Starting Price

Key Features

Best For

PriceLabs

$19.99/month

AI-based suggestions, PMS integration, customizable rules

Smaller to mid-sized portfolios

Beyond Pricing

$25/month

Detailed market insights, seasonal adjustments, custom strategies

Medium to larger portfolios

Wheelhouse

$29.99/month

Real-time market data, AI-driven pricing, demand trend forecasting

Managers focused on data

Each tool caters to different needs. PriceLabs emphasizes automation, Beyond Pricing offers in-depth market insights, and Wheelhouse specializes in forecasting demand trends.


How to Compare Tools

When choosing a tool, consider your portfolio size and management approach. Evaluate these key areas:

Feature Category

What to Look For

Data Analysis

Market trends and competitor tracking

Integration

Compatibility with channels and PMS systems

Customization

Flexible pricing rules, event handling, and stay requirements

Support

Training, customer service, and setup help


Maverick STR Revenue Management Strategies

Maverick STR offers a revenue management service that includes:

  • Implement Dynamic Pricing – We adjust your rates based on demand, seasonality, local events, and competitor pricing to ensure maximum earnings.
  • Analyze Market Trends – Our data-driven approach tracks shifts in travel demand, helping you stay ahead of the competition.
  • Maximize Occupancy & ADR (Average Daily Rate) – We find the perfect balance between keeping your property booked and maintaining high nightly rates.
  • Identify Revenue Opportunities – From extended stay discounts to minimum night adjustments to upsells, we apply smart strategies that increase your bottom line.
  • Seasonal Profiles - Configure seasonal profiles to adjust for monthly fluctuations based on ADR-weighted seasonality, ensuring maximum revenue throughout the year.
  • Custom Promotions & Rule Sets – Create tailored promotions and pricing rules to attract more bookings, optimize revenue, and adapt to market demand in real-time.
  • Leverage Performance Data – We continuously monitor key performance metrics to refine and improve your revenue strategy over time.
"Our dynamic pricing strategies are designed to respond to real-time market conditions while maintaining long-term profitability for property owners", says Chase Gillmore, founder of Maverick STR.

Once you've selected the right tools, the next step is using them effectively alongside focused market research.


Market Research Steps

To analyze competitor rates effectively, you need a structured approach to market research. This helps you understand your competition and strategically position your property.


Finding Direct Competitors

Identifying the right competitors is key to accurate benchmarking. Focus on properties that share these characteristics:

Criteria

What to Consider

Location

Same neighborhood or area with similar attractions

Property Type

Similar accommodation style (apartment, house, condo)

Target Market

Comparable guest segments (business travelers, families, etc.)

Price Range

Within 15-20% of your average daily rate

Amenities

Similar features and service levels

Choose 4-6 properties in your area that match these criteria. Update this list regularly as market conditions evolve. Once you’ve identified your competitors, the next step is to monitor their pricing strategies consistently.


Price Tracking Methods

Smith Travel Research (STR) reports, particularly the 'Monthly Performance at a Glance' feature, offer quick insights into competitor pricing and market trends.

Pay attention to factors like seasonal base rates, special promotions, minimum stay policies, weekday versus weekend pricing, and adjustments for local events. These patterns can reveal pricing opportunities.

But pricing isn’t everything. Understanding how your property stacks up in terms of features and amenities is just as important for staying competitive.


Property Features Analysis

Compare your property to competitors by focusing on these areas:

Analysis Area

Metrics to Track

Physical Features

Room count, square footage, recent renovations

Guest Amenities

Wi-Fi speed, parking availability, pool access

Service Level

Response times, cleaning frequency, check-in process

Guest Feedback

Review scores, common praise/complaints, response rates

Prioritize measurable factors that influence guest decisions. For example, track your RevPAR index compared to competitors. A score above 100 means you’re capturing more than your fair share of the market [1]. This analysis can highlight areas for improvement and help you adjust pricing to better meet guest expectations.

To maximize results, pair this research with dynamic pricing tools. These tools allow you to adjust rates in real time based on competitive data, helping you maintain your position in the market while boosting revenue.


Dynamic Pricing Guide

Dynamic pricing helps short-term rental (STR) owners boost revenue by adjusting rates in response to real-time market trends and competitor activity.


Why Use Dynamic Pricing

Analyzing competitor rates is a key part of setting dynamic pricing rules that adapt to market shifts. Here’s how it can benefit your STR business:

Benefit

Average Impact

Increased Revenue

15-25% more annual revenue

Higher Occupancy

10-20% improvement

Competitive Positioning

Stronger market presence year-round

Time Savings

30% less time spent on manual pricing


Price Change Triggers

A strong pricing strategy reacts to specific market signals. Here are some key triggers and how to handle them:

Trigger Type

Response Strategy

Seasonal Demand

Adjust rates by ±20-30% depending on the season

Local Events

Raise prices up to 50% for major events in the area

Competitor Adjustments

Match or undercut competitors within 24 hours

Occupancy Levels

Increase rates 5-10% when occupancy exceeds 80%

Last-Minute Availability

Discount unsold inventory by 15-20% within 72 hours


Pricing Rules and Tips

Start with a base rate that covers your costs and adds at least a 20% profit margin. Adjust this rate based on seasonal demand. Implement minimum stay requirements: 2-3 nights during peak times, 4-5 nights for major events, and single-night stays during slower periods and closer to booking dates.

Discount Strategies and Regular Monitoring

  • Implement a far-out premium of 10-15% for reservations made 90+ days in advance with a 3-night minimum.
  • Provide 15-20% off for stays of 7+ nights and 25-30% off for filling gap nights.
  • Keep an eye on rates:
    • Daily: Check competitor prices.
    • Weekly: Review occupancy levels.
    • Monthly: Analyze broader market trends.
    • Quarterly: Evaluate overall pricing performance.

Keep your prices consistent across all booking platforms, but incentivize direct bookings with perks like free upgrades or discounts. This approach can build guest loyalty while increasing revenue.

Leverage automated pricing tools to streamline these processes and ensure your rates adjust seamlessly based on your rules.


Data-Based Decisions


Main Performance Metrics

To shape effective pricing strategies, focus on these three key metrics:

Metric

Description

How It Helps

Daily Rate (ADR)

Average rate per occupied room

Helps pinpoint competitive pricing levels.

Occupancy Rate

Percentage of rooms booked

Guides pricing tweaks based on demand.

RevPAR

Revenue per available room

Combines rate and occupancy for revenue insights.


Reading Market Data

Regularly analyzing market data can uncover trends that inform pricing decisions. Here's what to keep an eye on:

Data Point

Review Frequency

What to Do

Seasonal Patterns

Monthly

Adjust rates for busy or slow seasons.

Local Events

Weekly

Increase prices during high-demand periods.

Competitor Changes

Daily

Stay aligned with market pricing shifts.

Occupancy Trends

Weekly

Refine pricing to match current demand.

Tools like PriceLabs and Beyond Pricing are great for spotting guest behavior trends and market changes, especially when it comes to seasonal shifts or competitor rate adjustments.


Using Data for Results

Here’s how to turn all that data into actionable pricing strategies:

  1. Monitor and Adjust
    • Use STR reports to compare your performance with the market.
    • Set your baseline rates based on historical trends.
    • Continuously adjust pricing to reflect:
      • Current market trends
      • Competitor pricing
      • Seasonal highs and lows
      • Local events or holidays
  2. Measure ImpactTrack booking speed, revenue growth, guest feedback, and market share to see how well your pricing strategy is working.

Pro Tip: Keep an eye on RevPAR - it’s the ultimate metric because it blends occupancy and rate performance into one clear measure of success.


Conclusion

By 2025, understanding and applying rate analysis will be essential for thriving in the STR market. Success hinges on monitoring key metrics like ADR, Occupancy Rate, and RevPAR, staying informed through market research, using flexible pricing strategies, and making data-driven decisions.


Action Steps

Here’s a quick recap of the strategies and tools discussed in this guide:

  • Set Up Your Tools Get your rate analysis platform up and running. Enable automated competitor tracking and configure price adjustment rules to stay ahead.
  • Analyze Your MarketIdentify 5-7 key competitors and keep an eye on their pricing trends over 30 days. Take note of any unique property features that could impact their rates.
  • Optimize Your PricingUse historical data to determine baseline rates. Apply the dynamic pricing methods mentioned earlier and revisit your strategies every month to fine-tune them.
: Keep an eye on RevPAR - it’s a great way to find the sweet spot between occupancy and pricing.

Related Blog Posts

Comentários


bottom of page